The federal government loses between $116 billion and $304 billion every single year to tax fraud, according to a striking new report released by the nonpartisan Government Accountability Office (GAO). This staggering loss amounts to roughly two to six percent of all federal taxes owed annually. To put this figure into perspective, the estimated fiscal drain from tax fraud alone exceeds the entire annual budget of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), which stands as one of the nation’s leading federal anti-poverty initiatives.
The comprehensive findings from the GAO highlight deep structural challenges within the United States tax system and add significant weight to ongoing arguments favoring a much simpler tax code, alongside vastly improved, better-coordinated fraud enforcement mechanisms at the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
What Is Tax Fraud?
To understand the scope of the problem, tax fraud must be viewed as a critical component of the broader tax gap—the total difference between the amount of federal taxes legally owed and the amount actually collected on time each year. What makes the recent GAO study unique is its pioneering attempt to formally measure explicit tax fraud within the broader tax gap. Historically, the IRS does not provide a separate, standalone estimate specifically tracking tax revenue lost directly to fraudulent activity.
Much of the revenue lost to tax fraud occurs within what economists and policymakers refer to as the "shadow economy." Economic literature reviewed by the GAO suggests that this hidden sector could equal anywhere from two to nine percent of the total Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
Tax Fraud, Tax Gap, and Improper Payments: What’s the Difference?
While tax fraud represents a substantial fiscal wound, it operates inside a much larger landscape of noncompliance known as the tax gap. As of tax year 2022, the overall tax gap sat at approximately $696 billion, accounting for roughly 15 percent of all taxes owed. This indicates that intentional fraud makes up about 17 to 44 percent of the total tax gap—a remarkably large share of uncollected public revenue.
After accounting for late payments and revenue successfully recovered through IRS audits, which totaled around $90 billion, the remaining net tax gap hovered at $606 billion.
A closer examination of the data reveals that the vast majority of the tax gap—about 77 percent—stems from the underreporting of income, with the remainder divided between nonfiling and the underpayment of taxes. Furthermore, roughly 71 percent of all underreporting occurs within the individual income tax category, heavily concentrated in sole proprietorship income. This specific segment accounts for $117 billion, or 17 percent, of the entire tax gap. According to IRS analyses, sole proprietorship income and other income streams characterized by little to no third-party reporting or wage withholding consistently exhibit the highest rates of noncompliance.
Closely related to this dynamic is the issue of improper payments tied to refundable tax credits, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (ITC) and the Child Tax Credit (CTC). Improper payments encompass any overpayments or underpayments that the federal government should not have made, or amounts that agencies could not verify as being distributed to the correct recipient in the correct amount. According to the latest estimates released by the Treasury Department and the IRS, improper payments across four major refundable tax credits reached $28.1 billion in fiscal year 2025.
However, government officials and policy experts emphasize that not all improper payments of refundable credits are the result of malicious or intentional fraud. The intricate rules and confusing administrative structures governing the EITC, CTC, and Premium Tax Credit frequently lead to honest, unintentional taxpayer errors. These mistakes ultimately result in overpayments or underpayments, all of which are officially categorized as improper payments in federal data reports.
Can Congress and the IRS Reduce the Tax Gap?
Experts readily acknowledge that completely eradicating tax fraud or fully closing the tax gap is an impossibility. Nevertheless, substantial policy and administrative improvements could significantly curb fraud and reduce the broader tax gap over time.
In its recent report, the GAO issued specific recommendations aimed at reining in tax fraud. Simultaneously, tax policy experts suggest that addressing the root causes of the broader tax gap requires confronting the immense complexity of the U.S. tax code.
Tax complexity has evolved into a severe economic problem. It routinely causes widespread taxpayer confusion, drives up unintentional errors, and imposes staggering compliance costs on the economy. This year alone, compliance costs are estimated to reach $544 billion—an amount nearly equivalent to the entire net tax gap itself. A significant portion of these complex rules and compliance burdens falls directly on American businesses.
The intricate nature of business taxation reflects the inherent difficulty of defining business income. This is compounded by tax rules that vary widely depending on business formation structures—such as C corporations, S corporations, partnerships, and sole proprietorships—alongside a web of information reporting requirements, like 1099 forms, designed to bolster system-wide compliance. Consequently, streamlining the tax code in a manner that simultaneously enhances compliance remains a formidable policy challenge.
One prominent reform option involves fundamental structural changes, such as replacing complicated corporate and business income taxes with a tax levied strictly on distributed profits, paired with a simplified individual income tax set at the exact same rate. This specific approach has been successfully implemented in Estonia and several other developed nations, yielding remarkably low compliance costs, a remarkably small corporate tax gap, and a highly competitive tax framework capable of generating revenues on par with other advanced economies. A more incremental approach would involve stripping away unnecessarily complicated deductions, targeted credits, minimum taxes, and other special provisions from the existing code.
Lawmakers in Congress can also curb improper payments associated with refundable credits by simplifying statutory definitions and streamlining the tax code. For example, the rules governing the EITC currently shift depending on a taxpayer’s filing status and the number of children they have, requiring parents and guardians to navigate a labyrinth of complex steps just to determine basic eligibility. Compounding the confusion, the qualifying child rules for the EITC differ from those governing the CTC.
Policy analysts have long argued that the EITC and CTC could be dramatically simplified by consolidating child-related benefits into a single, reformed child credit, while transitioning the EITC into a streamlined, per-worker incentive delivered regardless of family size. Similar reforms have previously been championed by lawmakers, including former Senator Mitt Romney of Utah.
Another viable strategy for reducing improper payments involves expanding the Treasury Department’s Do Not Pay system. As recent analyses have noted, the Treasury has recently bolstered the system and achieved measurable success in preventing erroneous payments to deceased individuals. However, the agency currently lacks the broad statutory authority required to expand the system effectively to check improper payments related to complex variables like employment status, income verification, and identity fraud.
Big Picture
The federal government loses hundreds of billions of dollars every single year to calculated tax fraud, alongside hundreds of billions more driven by unintentional noncompliance and administrative errors. While eliminating tax fraud entirely or fully closing the multi-billion-dollar tax gap remains an unattainable goal, federal lawmakers retain the power to enact meaningful reforms. By refining the tax code and modernizing IRS tax administration, policymakers can shrink the tax gap, secure public revenues, and close persistent vulnerabilities exploited by bad actors. At the very top of that reform agenda must be the simplification of a Byzantine tax code that continues to drive the widening chasm between taxes legally owed and taxes actually paid.
No comments yet. Be the first to join the conversation!