Following a series of crucial legislative and gubernatorial victories in this month’s midterm elections, Democrats have unlocked a potential pathway to neutralize the Electoral College—an institution that has historically cost their party at least two presidential contests over the course of the 21st century.
Formally abolishing the longstanding system, which mandates that U.S. presidents be selected through state-by-state slates of electors rather than a direct national popular vote, would ultimately require a constitutional amendment. However, legal scholars and political strategists note that the system could effectively be bypassed if a sufficient bloc of states commits to a legislative pledge known as the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
For this interstate agreement to take effect, its member states must collectively account for at least 270 electoral votes—the absolute majority required to secure the presidency. Over the past two decades, 18 Democratic-leaning states alongside the District of Columbia, representing a combined 222 electoral votes, have already enacted the compact into law. Recent midterm outcomes have placed the remaining threshold within reach for Democrats, should they choose to pursue it aggressively in the legislative sessions ahead.
What is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact?
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is a coordinated agreement among U.S. states to award all of their respective electoral votes to the presidential candidate who wins the overall national popular vote across the entire country.
This mechanism represents a dramatic departure from the current architecture of American presidential elections. At present, nearly every state utilizes a "winner-take-all" approach, allocating all of its electors to the candidate who garners a plurality or majority of votes within that specific state boundaries.
Because of this winner-take-all framework and the structural imbalances between individual states’ voter populations and their allocated electoral votes, a candidate can capture the presidency while losing the nationwide popular vote. This phenomenon has occurred five times in American history. Most recently, Donald Trump secured the presidency in 2016 despite losing the popular vote to Hillary Clinton. A similar outcome occurred earlier in the century during the 2000 election, when George W. Bush won the White House despite trailing Al Gore in the popular vote.
In contrast, the compact is designed to ensure that the candidate who wins the highest number of votes nationwide invariably claims the presidency.
The concept of states coordinating to circumvent the traditional mechanics of the Electoral College emerged directly from the fallout of the contentious 2000 election. In 2001, brothers Akhil Amar, a professor at Yale Law School, and Vikram Amar, a professor at the University of California Davis Law School, published an influential article outlining a framework similar to the modern compact. The formal National Popular Vote Interstate Compact was subsequently established roughly five years later, in 2006.
Since its inception, 18 states—California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington—alongside Washington, D.C., have passed legislation joining the agreement. Together, these jurisdictions represent 222 electoral votes, leaving the initiative 48 votes short of the 270-vote trigger needed to activate the pact.
For any individual state to join the compact, the measure must successfully pass through both chambers of its state legislature and receive the signature of the governor. In instances where a governor rejects the legislation, the legislature must muster a constitutional supermajority to override the executive veto and enact the statute into law.
How Democrats’ Midterm Wins Could Enable Them to Circumvent the Electoral College
During this month’s midterm elections, Democrats secured single-party control—often referred to as a "trifecta," where one party commands both legislative chambers and the governorship—in five additional states: Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin, and Nevada.
Combined, these five jurisdictions hold 61 electoral votes. This total provides more than enough leverage to push the compact past the 270-vote threshold if these states choose to ratify the agreement. In practical terms, the compact could reach the required majority even if only four of those five states sign on, provided the coalition includes Pennsylvania, which commands 19 electoral votes, and Michigan, with 15.
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro expressed openness to the concept during an appearance on a political podcast this month, stating that "the national popular vote makes sense" and adding that he would "work with lawmakers to figure out what the right mechanism is for moving forward on that."
Meanwhile, incoming Michigan Senate Democratic Leader Darrin Camilleri told POLITICO that while he is receptive to transitioning to a national popular vote system, he recognizes that such a move will trigger immediate legal pushback from Republicans.
"Other states that have done this are not going to be the tipping-point states. We very well could be one of those tipping point-states, and so I want to ensure that everybody is on the same page," Camilleri noted.
Is the Compact Constitutional?
The constitutionality of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact remains a subject of intense legal debate. Constitutional scholars warn that if the compact ever reaches the 270-vote threshold and goes into effect, it will instantly face rigorous court challenges.

Lawrence Lessig, a professor at Harvard Law School, argues that the compact is "clearly permissible" under the U.S. Constitution. He asserts that the framers "plainly meant to give to state legislatures the power to decide how to allocate their electors."
Conversely, opponents of the compact argue that it runs afoul of the Constitution’s "Compact Clause," according to Jennifer Hendricks, a law professor at the University of Colorado Boulder. That specific clause was originally drafted to prevent states from forming regional alliances that might threaten the supremacy and authority of the federal government.
However, Hendricks, aligning with Lessig, suggests that the compact does not cross the constitutional threshold of undermining federal authority.
"That’s not a problem here, because this is clearly a matter for the states under the Constitution," Hendricks said. "The federal government is not involved in deciding how to pick electors for the Electoral College."
How Would the Compact Impact Presidential Elections?
If implemented, the compact would fundamentally alter American presidential politics by making the national popular vote the sole determinant of the executive branch. Legal and political experts emphasize that the ramifications of this shift would extend far beyond the final tabulation of election results.
Adopting a popular vote system would "fundamentally change the dynamic of running for president" by leveling the political playing field across all fifty states, Lessig explained.
Under the current system, "every single election, candidates are focused on the swing states and not focused on the rest of the country, and that’s an injustice," he said. By replacing the existing model with the compact, candidates would transition "from a nine-state strategy to a 51-jurisdiction strategy."
"The reason why this is a good idea is that it means that every part of the country matters to the president," Lessig added, arguing that the reform would yield a significantly more representative democracy.
At the same time, Lessig noted that expanding the electoral battlefield would make modern campaigning exponentially more expensive, as candidates would be forced to contest votes nationwide rather than concentrating their financial and organizational resources solely in purple states like Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania.
Akhil Amar offered a balanced assessment of the compact, praising its underlying democratic principle while warning of potential operational hazards.
"The big pro is that it aims to vindicate the idea of equality: one person, one vote," Amar said. "The cons are that there are some serious issues of implementation that could arise, and some of them actually could be catastrophic because it’s a new scheme that has never been put into operation."
Amar outlined several scenarios that could threaten the operational stability of the compact. Individual states might attempt to manipulate the system by altering voter eligibility laws to favor specific political factions. Furthermore, in the event of an exceptionally close national election requiring a recount, non-compact states might refuse to participate or finance a recount if their internal tallies were not in dispute.
Another vulnerability, Amar noted, is the potential for member states to abandon the compact midstream. "You cannot pick our president on the basis of a scheme that only one party likes," he said, emphasizing that the partisan nature of the current coalition is its most significant vulnerability. "Because unless both parties buy in, one party will have an incentive to torpedo it."
To mitigate this partisan imbalance, Vikram Amar suggested that states could consider delaying the implementation of the compact to decouple it from immediate electoral calculations.
"There’s no way to know in 2044 which party is going to be favored in the Electoral College versus a national popular vote, so if we agree as a matter of principle that this is a fairer and saner way to elect a president, then just commit to it now, but defer or delay its implementation," he said. "That can overcome some of the partisan dimensions to it today."
Vikram Amar added that sustained, bipartisan familiarity with the compact over several election cycles could eventually generate the broad political momentum necessary for Congress to pursue a formal constitutional amendment abolishing the Electoral College altogether.
No comments yet. Be the first to join the conversation!