Monday, November 16, 2026
Housing and Real Estate

Title and Settlement Associations Urge Fifth Circuit to Keep FinCEN’s Real Estate AML Rule Vacated

Lina Hope
Font Size:
FB X WA TG

The high-stakes legal battle over the federal government’s efforts to crack down on anonymous real estate purchases is heating up again, with major industry groups stepping forward to defend a lower court decision that brought the policy to a halt.

The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network’s (FinCEN) Residential Real Estate Rule is not currently in effect, and the American Land Title Association (ALTA) and the Texas Land Title Association (TLTA) are fighting to ensure it stays that way. In late October, ALTA and TLTA filed amicus briefs asking the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit to uphold a ruling that vacated FinCEN’s nationwide anti-money laundering (AML) rule.

The controversial AML rule had mandated comprehensive reporting for any non-financed residential real estate transfer where ownership was held by an entity or trust. Crucially, the rule applied broadly across the country with no geographic or price threshold to separate routine transactions from high-risk deals.

The regulatory framework was overturned in late March by a federal judge in the Eastern District of Texas. The dramatic judicial intervention came after the law had been in effect for less than three weeks, freezing a mandate that many in the real estate and title industries argued was unworkable. In early May, FinCEN formally appealed the ruling, setting the stage for a critical appellate showdown.

This ruling and the subsequent appeal are part of a broader lawsuit originally filed by Flowers Title Companies, LLC. In its legal challenge, the company argued that FinCEN fundamentally lacked the authority under the Bank Secrecy Act to impose such sweeping, economy-wide reporting requirements on the residential real estate sector.

In their newly filed amicus briefs, ALTA and TLTA echoed and expanded upon these core arguments, telling the appellate court that the rule imposes significant costs and operational burdens on title and settlement professionals without adequately demonstrating that its benefits justify those requirements.

According to figures cited by ALTA, FinCEN’s initial cost estimate of implementing the policy—pegged at $559.4 million—was drastically too low. The association argued that FinCEN failed to fully account for the immense financial and operational toll placed on title companies. This includes the heavy expenses associated with comprehensive employee training, necessary technology and software changes, long-term record-keeping mandates, and the substantial time required to gather sensitive information from buyers and sellers.

Furthermore, ALTA highlighted a fundamental structural flaw in the regulation: title professionals have no legal authority or enforcement mechanism to force buyers or sellers to provide them with beneficial ownership information. The association also pointed out that financial institutions already collect beneficial ownership information directly from their business customers when bank accounts are opened, making the title industry’s mandated collection redundant and inefficient.

In its filing, the Texas Land Title Association added another layer of legal criticism, noting that the transactions FinCEN’s rule targets are routine and entirely legal. TLTA emphasized that FinCEN’s statutory legal authority under the governing statutes applies specifically to suspicious transactions, rather than sweeping an entire, massive class of routine commercial and residential transactions into a heavy regulatory net.

While it remains to be seen how the appeals court will ultimately rule on this complex issue, FinCEN has attempted to ease some immediate industry anxiety. The agency has stated that it will not require retroactive reporting for transactions that would have been reportable during the brief window the rule was active while these legal proceedings play out in court.

From the federal government’s perspective, the regulations were enacted to address a pressing national security and financial crime issue. FinCEN had argued that the rule was urgently necessary to close loopholes that allowed money launderers, drug traffickers, and other illicit actors to exploit shell companies and trusts to purchase residential property with complete anonymity. Federal regulators maintained that tracking these all-cash and non-financed entity transfers was essential to safeguarding the U.S. financial system from illicit capital flows.

The legal resistance to FinCEN’s mandate is not isolated to the Lone Star State. Fidelity National Financial (FNF), one of the nation’s largest title insurance companies, has also fiercely challenged FinCEN’s AML rule in court. However, that parallel legal challenge resulted in a conflicting outcome, with the rule initially being upheld in that specific venue. That adverse decision has since been appealed by FNF in the Eleventh Circuit, creating a complex patchwork of ongoing litigation across different federal circuits that could eventually draw the attention of higher judicial authorities.

No comments yet. Be the first to join the conversation!

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured Articles